• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • Our Mission
      • Political Islam
    • Areas of Expertise
      • Economic Warfare
        • Cyber Security
      • U.S. Policy
      • Anti-Corruption
      • Foreign Election Observing
      • Supporting Free Speech
        • Legislation
      • Impact of ACD’s Work
      • Free Speech Celebration, U.S. Senate
    • Board of Directors & Advisors
    • Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Subscribe
  • Our Impact
    • Endorsements
    • Additional Praise
  • Media
    • Events
      • Coming Events
    • Radio
    • Television
    • Youtube
  • Publications
    • All Posts Archive
    • Articles
    • Books
    • Papers
    • Presentations
    • Recommended Readings
  • Free Speech
    • Legislation & Support
    • Impact of ACD’s Work
      • Free Speech Celebration, U.S. Senate
      • Some Congressional Testimonies
      • 9/2010: SPEECH Act Celebration
  • Economic warfare
    • The Impact of Purposeful Interference on U.S. Cyber Interests
    • Cyber/Space, EMP Insecurity- Current and Future Threats
    • The Existential EMP Threat
    • New Strategies to Secure U.S. Economy from Cyber Attacks
    • Economic Warfare Subversions July 9, 2012
    • CyberSpace Security – Papers And Articles
    • Cyber Security
    • Da’esh “lite” North America Islamist – Sources
    • The Muslim Brotherhood and Da’esh “Lite” in North America
  • Support ACD
    • Donate
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
American Center for Democracy

American Center for Democracy

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • linkedin
  • Free Speech
  • U.S. Policy
    • U.S. Foreign Policy
  • Political Islam
    • Canada
    • Hamas
    • Iran
    • Islam
    • Muslim Brotherhood
    • Palestinian
    • United States
  • Narco-Terrorism
  • Middle East Conflicts
    • Iran
    • Israel
  • Global Conflicts
    • China
    • North Korea
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Soros
You are here: Home / Free Speech & Libel Tourism / RE: Libel Terrorism Protection Act, A.9652/S.6687

RE: Libel Terrorism Protection Act, A.9652/S.6687

February 11, 2008 by Letter to New York State Assemblyman Rory Lancman (D-25) and Senator Dean G. Skelos (R-9) | by Robert M. Morgenthau, District Attorney of the County of New York

Honorable Rory I. Lancman
Member of the Assembly
Legislative Office Building 549
Albany, NY 12248

Honorable Dean G. Skelos
Member of the Senate
Room 503, State Capitol
Albany, New York 12247

Re: Libel Terrorism Protection Act
A9652/S6687

Dear Assemblyman Lancman and Senator Skelos:

I am writing in support of the above-named legislation, which would provide authors, journalists and other writers in New York with a mechanism to prevent the enforcement of oppressive foreign defamation judgments in this state.

The case that prompted the introduction of this legislation shows just why New York writers need additional protections. Khalid bin Mahfouz, former head of the National Commercial Bank of Saudi Arabia, won a libel judgment in England against Rachel Ehrenfeld, a New York author, who wrote Funding Evil: How Terrorism Is Financed – and How to Stop It. Mahfouz claimed to have been libeled by statements in the book that Mahfouz and his family were financial sponsors of terrorism. Defending the suit, which Mahouz won by default, would have been prohibitively expensive and problematic for Ehrenfeld – British law makes it far more difficult for writers to defend libel suits than does the law in the United States.

Such foreign libel judgments, if they can be enforced in this country, have the potential to chill unfairly authors like Ehrenfeld from doing important work. Obviously, to write sensibly on international terrorism, an author has to discuss the role of wealthy sponsors of terrorism from the Middle East and elsewhere. Regrettably, authors who do so are subject to defamation lawsuits in jurisdictions, like the United Kingdom, which lack the constitutional protections that we have in the United States for authors who write about public issues and public figures. It is unconscionable that an author in New York, writing on a subject of vital importance to New Yorkers and to the nation, should be subject to the coercive effects of such foreign litigation.

In Ehrenfeld v. Mahfouz, however, the New York Court of Appeals ruled against Ehrenfeld in her effort to get a declaratory judgment prohibiting the enforcement of the British judgment in New York. Interpreting the relevant New York statute, the New York Court of Appeals held that New York lacked personal jurisdiction over Mahfouz, leaving Ehrenfeld without relief. Consequently, the libel judgment – which included money damages, the requirement of a public apology and an injunction against further publication of the book in England – is potentially enforceable against Ehrenfeld in New York. It is essential that New York law be amended promptly to enable New York authors to get declaratory relief in these circumstances.

Terrorist financing, the subject of Funding Evil, is of vital interest to all New Yorkers, in no small part because New York City remains a target of significance for international terrorists. It is especially important that New York authors have the freedom to investigate, write and publish on terrorism and other matters of public importance, subject only to limitations that are consistent with the U.S. Constitution. Passage of the legislation you have introduced will be an important step to providing such freedom.

Sincerely,

Robert M. Morgenthau

Filed Under: Free Speech & Libel Tourism, Supporting Free Speech

Primary Sidebar

ORDER THE SOROS AGENDA ...
Buy The Soros Agenda

Search ACD

Categories

The Soros Agenda

g. soros

Soros: The Man Who Would Be Kingmaker, Part I

Rachel Ehrenfeld & Shawn Macomber

Soros: The Man Who Would Be Kingmaker, Part II

Soros: The Man Who Would be Kingmaker, Part III

Soros: The Man Who Would be Kingmaker, Part IV

Spotlight

quote by j.woolsey obama signing Rachel's law chemical terrorism transportation terrorism nuclear threats on the rise islamist incitement winning the cyberwar gps concepts and misconceptions libel tourism

Tags

antisemitism Caliphate Canada capital punishment China Christians Daniel Haqiqatjou Dawah Disinformation genocide Hamas Iran ISIS Islam Islamic Party of Ontario Islamic Relief Canada Islamization Islamophobia Israel J. Millard Burr Jews jihad Justin Trudeau LGBT liberalism Liberal Party Muslim Brotherhood Muslims NCCM Norman Bailey Ontario Palestine Political Islam Quran Russia Salaheddin Islamic Centre Saudi Arabia Sharia Sol W. Sanders SOROS Syria Terrorism Toronto US women's rights

Footer

About ACD

ACD is a New York-based 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization, which monitors and exposes the enemies of freedom and their modus operandi, and explores pragmatic ways to counteract their methods.

Endorsements

"The ACD/EWI ability to predict future threats is second to none"

- R. James Woolsey, former Director of Central Intelligence

- - - More Endorsements - - -

Follow ACD!

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • linkedin

Copyright © 2023 | The American Center for Democracy is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization. Your contribution is tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.